Research
Meta-analysis: Risks of refractive lens exchange (RLE) are higher than those of cataract surgery
Advances in modern premium lenses have contributed to the increasing trend of performing early cataract surgery as early as one’s mid-40s. The goal of the procedure is to enable patients to see without glasses once presbyopia sets in. But is this so-called refractive lens exchange just as safe as cataract surgery? A meta-analysis investigated this question.1
What is the difference between cataract surgery and refractive lens exchange?
During cataract surgery, the eye’s lens—which is usually clouded due to aging—is replaced with an intraocular lens (IOL). The first symptoms of cataracts typically appear around age 60; by the early 70s, about 50 percent of people suffer from lens clouding and undergo surgery. Cataract surgery is the only treatment available and is performed about 900,000 times a year in Germany alone. It is considered so safe that it can even be recommended in earlier stages of the disease.
Increasingly, multifocal lenses or so-called EDOF lenses with modern optical designs are being used, which allow patients to be free of glasses after cataract surgery.
Refractive lens exchange is a possible treatment for presbyopia, which is the age-related decline in the eye’s ability to “focus” on near objects. The first symptoms may appear around age 45. In this procedure—as an alternative to reading glasses or progressive lenses—modern multifocal lenses or EDOF lenses are implanted, which can enable sharp vision at various distances. In most cases, there is no lens opacity.
After the procedure, cataract surgery is no longer necessary. Nevertheless, the risks associated with the surgery should be considered, as there is no medical necessity for lens replacement if the lens is still clear.
Key finding of the meta-analysis
Retinal detachment occurs about twice as often following refractive lens exchange
A recently published meta-analysis 1 examined how high the risk of retinal detachment is after lens exchange compared to that after cataract surgery. The analysis included 40 studies involving a total of 8,592,380 eyes, of which 20,264 underwent refractive lens exchange and 8,572,116 underwent cataract surgery.
Retinal detachment can be classified as a rare complication following cataract surgery (1 in 1,000) and as an uncommon complication following refractive lens exchange (1 in 500).
The key finding of the meta-analysis shows that retinal detachment occurred twice as often after refractive lens exchange (RLE) as after cataract surgery, with a follow-up period of at least 24 months (median 4 years). Thus, retinal detachment can be classified as a rare complication following cataract surgery (1/1,000) and as a less common complication following RLE (1/500).
Highest risk: severe myopia and age under 50
Two risk factors were identified:
High myopia: Eyes with severe nearsightedness had a significantly higher risk of retinal detachment than eyes with normal vision or farsightedness. This is consistent with clinical experience. This is because the eyeball of a nearsighted eye is longer, which causes the structures at the back of the eye to be more stretched and leads to peripheral retinal degeneration more frequently. The higher the degree of myopia, the higher the risk.
Age under 50: Patients under the age of 50 also had a higher risk of retinal detachment. According to the authors, one possible explanation for this could be that in older patients, the vitreous humor had already detached prior to surgery. This reduces the traction on the retina following the procedure.
Safety is our top priority
The meta-analysis confirms our strategy for correcting presbyopia: safety comes first. If the eye’s natural lens is clear, there is no reason to replace it. Instead, for over 10 years we have been recommending specialized laser procedures that can also correct presbyopia. This includes the PresbyEDoF laser eye surgery introduced by Dr. Detlev R.H. Breyer, which creates a type of “overlapping” visual acuity and enables clear vision at both far and intermediate distances (computer distance). The risks associated with laser eye surgery are significantly lower than those of lens replacement. Should a cataract develop 10 or 15 years later, the implantation of monofocal lenses is sufficient to continue benefiting from the laser correction.