News
Munich Higher Regional Court Rules That Focus's "Doctor" Seal Is Permissible
On May 22, 2025, in a case brought by the Competition Center, the Munich Higher Regional Court (OLG) ruled that the “Doctor’s Seal” used by Focus magazine was permissible. This overturned the decision handed down two years earlier by the Munich Regional Court. The selection criteria for the doctors were entirely reasonable, the court wrote in its reasoning for the judgment.
Physician endorsements are considered editorial recommendations
In its reasoning for the judgment, the Higher Regional Court explained that consumers viewed the two seals—“Top Physician” and “Focus Recommendation”—as editorial recommendations rather than official certification seals. Consequently, there was no anti-competitive misleading conduct. Unlike the Munich Regional Court, the Munich Higher Regional Court agreed with the publisher’s argument and held that the criteria used to designate the honored physicians as “Top Physicians” were entirely transparent. The comparison of the doctors was objectively based on essential, relevant, verifiable, and typical characteristics of the services. (Judgment of May 22, 2025, Case No. 29 U 867/23 – not yet final).
Dr. Breyer has been listed as a "Focus Top Physician" since 2013
Since 2013, Dr. Detlev R.H. Breyer (FWCRS) has been listed among Focus magazine’s top physicians for refractive surgery and cataract surgery. In 2025, Focus also included him in its list for corneal diseases.
Inclusion in the Focus Top Doctors lists is based on a defined survey methodology. The selection criteria include, among other things, a leadership position at a hospital or medical facility, recommendations from colleagues, patient recommendations, experience, scientific commitment, and much more. Only those who achieve above-average ratings across all criteria are included in the Focus Top Doctors lists.
Stern has also listed Dr. Detlev R.H. Breyer in its Stern list of doctors for refractive surgery since 2022. The Stern lists are compiled using criteria comparable to those of the Focus physician lists. They are produced by the independent research institute Munich Inquire Media, which developed the methodology for the Focus physician lists in the early years and was responsible for selecting the physicians.