News
Are EDoF lenses also recommended for cataracts and macular degeneration?
A new review examined whether extended depth-of-field intraocular lenses (EDoF-IOLs) should also be used in people suffering from cataracts and macular degeneration.1 To this end, a literature review and a survey of committee members of the European Society of Refractive Surgeons (ESCRS) were conducted. Dr. Detlev R.H. Breyer initiated and co-authored the publication. He has been implanting and researching EDoF lenses for about 15 years.
As the literature review showed, there is growing evidence of the potential benefits of EDoF IOLs in selected patients with mild to moderate macular disease, although concerns remain. The survey found that 59 percent of respondents considered EDoF IOL implantation in this patient group to be “worth a try.”
Cataracts and Macular Diseases
Is it possible to see without glasses despite macular degeneration?
More and more people with cataracts who opt for lens surgery want to be free from reading glasses or progressive lenses after the procedure. To plan the cataract surgery and select an appropriate lens, various examinations are performed beforehand, ranging from the anterior segment to the retina, macula, and optic nerve. If a macular disease is diagnosed at an early or intermediate stage, the treating eye surgeon must determine which intraocular lens is appropriate. Are the intraocular lenses with extended depth of focus (EDoF) and refractive optics introduced in recent years also a potential option for these patient groups?
While only 7.4% of the experienced surgeons surveyed reported routinely implanting EDoF IOLs in patients with maculopathy, as many as 37% stated that they perform this procedure at least occasionally.
Macular Diseases
A Paradigm Shift in Lens Selection
In the past, traditional multifocal lenses were considered generally unsuitable for patients with macular diseases. Due to differences in optical properties, specialists in refractive surgery increasingly believe that this assessment cannot be readily applied to EDoF lenses.
Unlike traditional multifocal intraocular lenses (MIOLs) with diffractive optics, which split light into multiple focal points, EDoF IOLs with refractive optics provide a continuous visual range across multiple focal points—without splitting the light. As a result, contrasts and colors are perceived more intensely. Glare, on the other hand, occurs less frequently than with conventional MIOLs.
According to the authors, these optical properties of EDoF lenses and their differences from conventional MIOLs may also be beneficial for people with early- and mid-stage macular diseases. However, their use has not yet been sufficiently researched.
The authors analyzed the existing literature on the use of refractive EDoF IOLs in the context of macular diseases and identified key factors that should be considered when selecting suitable patients. These include, among others:
Stage and rate of progression of the macular disease
Presence of diabetic eye diseases
Visual acuity under various lighting conditions
Expectations regarding visual outcomes after surgery
Adaptation to visual perception with an EDoF IOL
In particular, the brain’s ability to adapt to the new visual experience—known as neuroadaptation—can also help people with macular diseases achieve better visual quality. Expectations regarding visual outcomes after surgery, particularly in the context of macular disease, should be discussed openly in advance.
Interestingly, specialized lenses developed for macular diseases have not been universally praised in the literature, as some patients found it difficult to adapt to these magnifying lenses. These lenses also posed a challenge for diagnostic evaluation of the eye following implantation.